I fear this will be the most sacrilegious work I'll ever write.
It's funny how often I've said that and yet how often I've repeated my mistake. Before I begin, I'd like all of my faithful, shariah-abiding, orthodox and adamantly religious friends to know that I mean no disrespect to anything or anyone, especially not God. I believe in a Higher Being, do what little I can to sustain my Faith and though my perception of Him may differ from yours, even the finest of the sufis and ulema agree that such differences are common [I have no direct references but search the statement and you will find plenty that supports this].
Even so, this piece of writing is just a thought that my foul mind brought forth one dull morning and though I should've simply ignored it, I decided to write it down so you may correct me along with those who might have thought this way once upon a time.
According to the Biblical, Quranic and other monotheistic (and often not so monotheistic) literature, Lucifer became Satan because of pride, ego and haughtiness. He could not accept that a creature made of earth would be preferred to a creature made of fire. Another version says it was because of some interstellar conflict and Satan wasn't willing to become some crap-making fleshling's bitch. Yet another version states that it was simply meant to be.
I'm told that all versions of this story are pretty much the same in every religion, but my version will slightly detract towards a more fictitious angle. So here's how it rolls (for those who already know the beginning, I'm truly sorry but it had to be stated to build the thesis):
Lucifer is not only the leader of the Jinns but the most forthright non-angel being ever created. To empathize with him, imagine a foot soldier borne and bred to serve nothing but the Divine Being, to know nothing but servitude and devotion towards the God you've come to admire, love, fear, respect and submit your existence to. He is the be and do of your entire existence. Though this is true of even angels, it was precisely because of his not being an angel that his staunchness and servitude were so immense.
Then one day - or time, moment, eon, whatever perception of time that prevails where there is no Time - a gathering is called by the Being. Rumor spreads in silent but pervasive whispers among the angelic and non-angelic entities that a new creation has been created in the Creator's own image (NOTE: What is about to be stated now is my perception and must be read as a fictitious interpretation, nothing more). All the creations are left in awe and bewilderment as to what their Almighty Creator must've brought forth and what it's purpose must be. They speak secretly among themselves, asking one another inquisitively.
The Angel of Death suggests a dark angel, one that is a hybrid of angels and jinns yet more powerful than both, divine like the Lord they serve. He elaborates on how this creation will supersede the higher order angels thus replacing the current hierarchy and act as the body of control over all that exists. The Angel of Stars laughs at this notion and suggests that the love the Higher Being has for His creations would never allow the present order of things to come under jeopardy. She suggests a creature so brilliant it would illuminate the newly created universe, thus acting as a divine radiance on all that is and isn't. She goes on about how it will prove to existence that it is the Almighty Being that is and that His grasp surpasses the inexistent. The Angel of Probability & Randomness nullifies all these "ridiculous conjectures" and states that the pattern exhibited by the Divine thus far suggests a creation of grandeur, larger than anything they can possibly imagine. He displays on a hologram, first, a Poisson graph depicting the pattern that previous creations showed and how the new creation has to be larger, followed by a pictorial depiction of the creature itself. Based on all existing data, he says the image will look like this: a picture of a large white circle with a small black circle in the middle appears on the hologram. A small note at the bottom of the picture reads "Scale: 1mm = 1,000 Dm" (Dm, Divine meter = 1,000 googolplex of terameters).
At this point, the Angel of Humor comes cartwheeling between the crowd, then hops to the Angel of Wrath and yells "TUK-A-DURR" to his face. "The creature", he says, turning to the gathering, "will be ...". He pauses, eyes as wide as the sun, about to reveal the secret that none but he knew. The gathering of angels leans forward.
"A MONKEY!" He squeals and jumps back into the crowd, yelling "TUK-A-DURR" as he cartwheels away. Some angels yell out in disapproval, some seek repentance from God while others simply laugh at the absurdity of the idea.
Meanwhile, Gabriel and Lucifer stand firm side-by-side, looking on at the throne of God, awaiting His appearance. The angels and jinns had been turning to the two simultaneously, asking if they had any knowledge of the creature to be presented. While Gabriel simply tells them to seek His mercy and be patient, Lucifer quietly continues to look at the throne, ignoring all the irrelevant inquiries, a forbidding yet humble look in his eyes. He is neither jealous nor proud at this moment, simply anxious and curious as to the purpose set for him by his Lord with regards to this new creation. Fearful, obedient, humble.
All of a sudden, a light appears on the throne and the creatures silence themselves, humility overcoming their whims. Like a sunrise, its radiance gradually amplifies, reaching far, illuminating all the creatures. When a form appears on the throne, the creatures bow down, prostrating themselves to the Form. Lucifer clears his mind of all else except his Lord, his Creator, his Purpose. Though all creatures were equally subservient to the Almighty, Lucifer's regard for the prostration was incomparable. To Him, it symbolized his devotion to God and nothing else.
On His Command, they rise back up, resurrecting from their state of trance. God speaks in a mighty voice that echoes throughout existence itself. The creatures are now focusing on nothing but Him, their gaze locked on His Presence. He tells them that a new creation has been created, one in His own image: one that can reason, learn, adapt and discover as no other creation has ever done. But He states that before it can be shown, all creations must prostrate to it.
Like a windstorm that annihilates entire civilizations in one fell swoop, Lucifer's world is left in disarray. A prostration? The symbol of servitude to the one he revered, loved, feared for eternity will now be presented to some other creature? He is still not proud, still not egotistic about fire being his source of creation and earth being the new creation's source. A part of him tells him to ignore this and remember that it is God he serves and he must do as he is commanded.
But the pain is insurmountable. The anguish is too much to bear and he clutches his breast, walking slowly towards his Lord, hoping He would make him understand and appease the pain. But when the creature is finally presented, Lucifer stops dead in his track. The angels and non-angels glare at this creature named Man, in bewilderment.
In a precision that would put the London Symphony to shame, the angels and non-angels prostrate together. "Told you it was a monkey!" The Angel of Humor whispers to the Angel of Wrath, who simply grunts at the comment and continues to prostrate obediently.
Like a single palm tree on an infinite desert plain, Lucifer stands straight, not in defiance but in shock. Gabriel, the only angel Lucifer ever truly respected, cries from his prostration.
"Luke! What are you doing? This is no time for being resilient. Just prostrate!"
"No, Gabriel," he responds, his gaze still locked on God, "not to him. My prostration belongs to God."
"Lucifer! As your superior, I command you to return and prostrate." Gabriel calls desperately in loud whispers. "You can seek His council after this. Do not earn His anger! Lucifer!"
Lucifer begins to walk towards God, his hand still clutching his chest, ignoring the calls of his comrade behind him.
The Almighty had been hearing this conversation since it began and turning to him, verbally commands Lucifer to prostrate.
"Why, my Lord? My Almighty, most High, most Revered God. My true Master. My Creator. Why to him? My prostrations belong to you!" He falls to his knees, weeping in despair.
"Do not question me, Lucifer." His resounding voice brings humility to everything. "You do not know what I know. You will simply have to trust Me."
"But my Beloved, my prostration is the symbol of my servitude to you. I implore you! Ask me to do anything, anything but prostrate to this creature." He bows his head down, clutching the ground before his Lord as he cries aloud.
"Lucifer! Arise!"
He does so, continuing to plead for His mercy, begging Him to change the command for this occasion.
"Please, my Lord," he cries, "please do not ask me to do this. I have never asked you to change Your command. But I beg you. Do not ask me to prostrate before another."
God's divine aura changes from supremacy to mercy. He beckons Lucifer to his feet, facing him. In his humility, Lucifer does not look back but simply bows his head.
"Lucifer, you are my servant, undoubtedly one of the best I have ever created. And I love you as I love all creations." His voice is comforting, like a nurturing mother calming her child. "But it disturbs me to see you defiant over this command."
"Then why ask me to prostrate to another? I am no angel. I was not created to be subservient. I was created to be able to reason, to make my own decisions, to choose my own destiny. And I chose You.
"They prostrate to him merely because it is what they have been created to do," he points to the thousands of bowed angels and jinns on his side, "but you gave me a choice. A prostration may simply be another action they perform in Your name, but it means everything to me. It makes me who I am, it differentiates me from them. That where they are obedient to you because you created them as such, I am obedient because that is what I have chosen. This prostration is my symbol to you, my only proof that I have chosen You. And if you ask me now to prostrate to another, then you take that away from me. And I will do whatever it takes to let that from happening."
The aura of mercy fades. A tense atmosphere prevails over the throne. As the angels and non-angels continue to prostrate, the Divine Radiance fades from Lucifer. But Lucifer remains defiant, showing his commitment to God, even if that meant defying God himself.
"Then you leave me no choice." He commands the bowed figures to rise and made witness to His command. "Lucifer, you are hereby declared wretched and forsaken. Leave My throne! Abandon My presence! You shall never return to this sacred place again."
As the Divine Radiance begins to fade, Lucifer falls to his knees. Never in his entire existence had he imagined that the One he loved so dearly would shun him like this. "Abandon My presence!" The words kept echoing inside him. His Father, his Master, his Purpose.
As the figures behind him begin to rise, Gabriel rushes to Lucifer's side.
"Luke, listen to me. What you did was stupid and arrogant. He would never have given this command had you spoken to Him in private." Being the first of creations, the two leaders shared a relationship of mutual respect and love that everyone knew about but never spoke of. As superiors to their subjects, they had always been forbidding, treating one another with a facade of staunchness and discipline. But now, seeing his comrade in despair, humiliated publicly, Gabriel sat himself down beside the shrugged figure and placed his hands on Lucifer's shoulders, reassuring him that God's anger was merely transient and would soon be replaced with mercy.
"Take your arms off of me! You patronizing, self-righteous trash of existence!" A look had appeared in Lucifer's eyes that Gabriel had never seen before, a look so vile it reminded him of the day he was shown Hell.
Lucifer turned to Man. The figure stood there, its eyes closed, arms and legs stretched out like Da Vinci's Vitruvian Man. You, he thought to himself, you are the reason my Lord has denied me His presence. A surge of thoughts struck him as he contrived about what must be done next.
Weep. No. Be strong.
Repent. No. Must prove to Him my servitude.
Destroy. Who? Man. No. God would never allow it.
Burn him. He is earth. I am fire. No. It proves nothing.
Befoul him. Seduce him. Teach him. Yes, befoul man. Befoul the clay statue.
The thought made him cackle outloud.
"Lucifer?" Gabriel had backed off now, a mixed expression of shock and concern overcoming him. "What is wrong with you, old friend? Do not do this to yourself. There is a way out of this."
"You're right. There is a way. There is always a way." Lucifer stood up slowly, his figure dark as the depths of oblivion. The divine radiance that was so luminescent off of him once had now dissipated.
"A clay figure, my Lord?" He yelled to the Radiance still revolving on the throne. "You have broken the heart of 'one of the best servants you have ever created' for THAT?"
The Radiance stopped revolving. All angels and non-angels froze still, all except Lucifer. His chest was protruding, gaze locked on the Radiance with an insuperable hatred.
Fearing the worst, Gabriel finally spoke.
"Please, my Lord. He is not himself. Forgive him for his defiance. He will bow."
"Be silent, Gabriel," God shunned the leader of the angels, "lest you wish to share the same fate as the one who dares to raise his voice to Me."
With nothing more that he could do, Gabriel simply bowed himself in prostration, praying that Lucifer would come to his senses.
"You know I will never bow." His eyes were still locked on the Radiance, unflinching. "And you knew this would happen even before you gathered us."
"No, Lucifer. You have chosen your own fate. But on Gabriel's request, I will give you one last chance to repent."
Lucifer turned to Man. "Him," he said, pointing towards the naked figure. "Let me stay with him. Let me teach him. After all that's been said and done, I am still Your slave and You are still my Master. Do not make me worthless yet. Let me accompany him to wherever he goes, whatever he does, even whatever he thinks. Let me be the balance in his life. His darkness to shield him from Your blinding light. His shade against Your blistering radiance. His knowledge in Your universe of ignorance. His courage against Your wrath." He turned to Gabriel, still addressing God. "His curiosity against Your apathy." Then to all the angels and non-angels. "His freedom against Your servitude." He then turned back to God and spoke slowly, clearly enunciating every word. "And finally, his comfort in Your world of despair."
A commotion began to brew in the background as the non-angels conversed among themselves in whispers. The angels remained silent, still, obedient. Gabriel did his best to hold his tears in but couldn't. Every part of him was aching to smite the fool that was the closest thing to a brother he ever had.
"Very well." With just two words, the entire gathering went silent. "So it shall be. You will be given respite with Man in his abode, you and whichever of your kind that wishes to join you. You will whisper your whispers to this Man and his partner in Eden, from where they shall be teleported [for lack of a better word] to Earth. There they shall create many offspring and you shall befoul them all. All except those who remain true to Me."
"Remain true to You? REMAIN TRUE TO YOU?" His voice rose again, this time in rage rather than resilience. "After I have spoken to them, none shall remain true to You. None! I will speak to them about Your true nature, about how servitude to you will bring them nothing but despair."
He turned around, remnants of his earlier tears still drying on his face. As he began walking away, Gabriel's eyes caught his. There was a mixture of grief and anger in the angel's eyes, but they quickly bowed down. Lucifer continued walking, ignoring the gesture, but then stopped at Gabriel's side.
"Join me, old friend. Join me so that we may prove to Him that we will defy anything that dares to swerve us away from Him, even He Himself." He looked up at him. "You are not a sheep, Gabriel. You do have a choice."
"Listen to yourself, Lucifer." Gabriel was now looking back at him, at his dark eyes. "Defy God for God's sake? Why can you not understand your folly here?" He took a step to the side so he could face him completely. "But you are right. I do have a choice. And I choose God." He continued. "Join you? Quite the contrary, old friend. I will protect Man from you, protect them from your destruction. You are no longer Lucifer, you are Satan! And I regret the day I called you my brother."
Lucifer's composure remained the same, simply taking a deep breath of indifference. "So be it. But sooner or later, you will see that this is His doing, not mine. He created Hell, not me. He could have stopped me from doing what He undoubtedly knows I will do. Call me the enemy, call me Satan. See if I give a fuck!" And with that, he walked away.
The gathering had now been divided. While some Jinns remained with the group of angels that had cleared the way for the defiant Lucifer, others were eagerly awaiting his arrival at the end of the hall [again, for lack of a better word]. He turned to address this group, but spoke loud enough that the other angels and non-angels could hear him.
"Come, you foul creatures! He says you will share my curse, I say you will share my freedom. He says you will burn in hell, I say that you will be the glorious fire itself. He says what you are doing is wrong, I say what you are doing is noble. He says there are good humans, I say let us make Him regret the day He spoke of their goodness. We are the first of creation, we are finer ones, we roamed the universes when there were none. Let us prove to Him the power of the Jinn race. Let us prove to Him," he then took a curtsy bow in mockery, "our devotion for Him".
A cacophony of roars and laughters filled the throne as the Jinns made their way out. When one yelled, "Hail Lucifer", he grabbed him from the collar, glared down his whimpering figure, then smiled and said calmly, "Call me Satan. Satan, the most vile". As the group continued to march out, laughing and bellowing in their newfound freedom, Lucifer remained back, turning to look one last time on his Master, his Creator, his Beloved for thousands of eons.
He recalled the day he was first created and the blissful radiance that had filled him the first time his Lord had spoken to him. You are my creation. I will provide for you, sustain you, love you, protect you. I will be sacred to you as you will be to me. You will be mine and I shall be yours.
His Lord was looking back at him, an aura of wrath surrounding His throne. But behind this, there was a hidden hope that His creation would return to Him. For a moment, even Lucifer felt a slight warmth emanating from his breast, trying to overcome his rage.
Alas, my friends, that warmth was not to last. For Lucifer simply turned away, dejected, forsaken yet strangely content with his new title. "Satan. I like the sound of that. I know Man will too."
And that, friends and now-potential foes, is why Satan does what he does and is what he is. Like I said before, this is not based on any literature, thought or religion. This is simply a fictitious over-exaggerated version of Lucifer's becoming Satan. I know that in playing the devil's advocate and sympathizing with him, I have jeopardized my own self-righteous image and consequently some of you must be furious. But the truth is, if Satan truly does exist, then he must be smart (I mean come on, the guy rules the financial world and has got to be the finest social and clinical psychologist ever). And if he is smart, I doubt he'd let petty things like ego and pride overcome his destiny, especially if it meant being dejected by God. So, no, tell me I'm wrong but I do not think it was ego or pride. With what we've been told about Satan, pride was irrelevant.
So bottomline, my story only provides an alternative answer. God knows better!